BuzzMelt review

Clayface review: gross, gripping body horror with a story you've seen before

Clayface review: DC's adults-only horror film follows Matt Hagen, a rising actor whose face is ruined, and the risky treatment that gives it back at a terrible price. Tom Rhys Harries and the gruesome make-up effects are the big draw. The revenge story is familiar, though, and the tone wobbles in the second half.

3.5 3.5 out of 5 stars Watch 100%

Clayface review: a still from Clayface, Tom Rhys Harries as Matt Hagen with his face warped and split
Image: DC Studios. Via TMDB.

DC's newest film has no capes and no Batman. Instead, Clayface is an adults-only body horror story about a handsome young actor who loses his face, and it wants you to squirm. The short version of our Clayface review: Tom Rhys Harries is terrific and the make-up effects are properly gross, but the revenge story is one you have seen before. Horror fans will have a good time. Casual DC fans can wait for streaming.

A quick warning first. The film is rated A in India, R in the US and 18 in the UK, with graphic disfigurement, lingering wounds and bloody violence. Critics are mostly kind but not excited: at the time of writing, Rotten Tomatoes shows 75% positive from 155 reviews, while Metacritic gives it 59 out of 100.

What it's about

Matt Hagen (Harries) grew up on the streets of Gotham and is now on his way to being a Hollywood leading man. Then a local crime boss steps in, and Matt is left badly disfigured. His team drops him. With nothing left, he signs up for a new, untested treatment that gives him his old face back. But the cure also loosens his grip on reality, and Matt starts down a path of revenge.

Matt Hagen lies in a hospital bed, his face wrapped in bloody bandages
Matt Hagen after the attack that ends his career Image: DC Studios. Via TMDB.

Naomi Ackie plays Caitlyn Corr, a doctor who grows close to Matt. Eddie Marsan is Frank Fitzpatrick, his manager, and Max Minghella is John Borrelli, a Gotham detective. David Dencik plays Markos Szabo, one of the city's gangsters. James Watkins (Eden Lake, Speak No Evil) directs from a script by Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini. This is a standalone story, so you need no other DC film to follow it.

Tom Rhys Harries carries it

Harries is the main reason to go. Nearly every critic we read singles him out. He makes Matt charming at first, then hard to look at, then hard to trust. Much of that work happens under heavy make-up and effects. Even so, you never stop feeling for the man underneath, and that keeps the film from turning into a simple monster show.

Ackie is warm and grounded as Caitlyn. Some critics liked her scenes with Harries a lot, while others found the romance forced. Marsan and Minghella get less to do. In fact, a few reviews called Minghella's detective the dullest part of the film.

What works

First, the gore. Watkins takes his time with Matt's injuries and treatments, and the film is not shy about any of it. One scene on a plane, which the trailers already tease, is the moment most critics remember. Practical make-up does the heavy lifting, with computer effects added on top.

The look helps too. Cinematographer Rob Hardy shoots Gotham in rain, grey and neon, which gives the film an old-school crime noir feel.

It also matters that the film stands alone. There is no universe homework, and it doesn't stretch past two hours. The warmest reviews called it one of the year's nicer surprises, a DC film happy to be small and mean.

Where it falls short

Almost every negative Clayface review we read comes back to the story. Strip away the gore and this is an old tale of a ruined man, a kind woman and a list of people to punish. Critics kept naming Darkman, The Phantom of the Opera and The Fly, and the film adds little to them. It is also slow to start. Later, the second half turns more generic, and some found the ending predictable rather than sad.

The tone is the other problem. The film mostly plays it grim. However, it slips now and then into jokey moments that sit oddly next to the horror. The gangsters get some corny lines. Some reviewers felt the shape-shifting effects look weak next to the practical work. And for a horror film, it isn't that scary. Several critics said the jump scares got more laughs than gasps.

Clayface review: should you watch it?

Yes, if you like body horror and don't mind a familiar plot. Fans of The Substance or Cronenberg's The Fly will find plenty to wince at. By contrast, if you want a superhero film, this is not it. If gore bothers you, skip it.

Clayface opened in cinemas in India, the US and the UK on Friday, 23 October 2026. In India it carries an A certificate, so it is for adults only. At the time of writing, it had made ₹1.83 crore net in India over its first two days, per the BuzzMelt movie page. No streaming date has been announced yet.

It runs 109 minutes. The tone is dark and bloody, with a few odd laughs. Watch the official trailer first. If that makes you squirm, the film goes much further. Seen it already? Add your own Clayface review on the title page.

Sources: TMDB, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Time Out, Screen Daily, Dread Central, The Boston Globe, Rotten Tomatoes first reviews

Our verdict on Clayface (2026)

3.5 3.5 out of 5 stars

Worth a trip to the cinema if you love gory body horror and can live with a familiar revenge plot. Casual DC fans can wait.

This is BuzzMelt's own review. What members think of Clayface is on its movie page.