BuzzMelt review

Spider-Man Brand New Day review: Tom Holland's best Peter Parker, in a film that takes too long to start

Spider-Man Brand New Day review: forgotten by everyone he loves, Peter Parker faces a villain no one can see in a smaller, sadder Marvel film. Critics praise Tom Holland's most grown-up turn, Jon Bernthal's Punisher and the swinging action. A slow first hour, a thin villain plan and a 145-minute runtime hold it back.

4.5 4.5 out of 5 stars Watch 79%

Spider-Man Brand New Day review: a still from Spider-Man: Brand New Day
Image: Marvel Studios, Columbia Pictures. Via TMDB.

Tom Holland's fourth solo outing as Spider-Man picks up where Spider-Man: No Way Home left him: alone, with nobody left who remembers Peter Parker. Our verdict in a line: Holland has never been better in the suit, and the film around him is smaller, sadder and more grown-up than the last three. However, the first hour drags, the villain is thin, and 145 minutes is a lot. Most critics liked it, and so do our members.

What it's about

The story is set some time after No Way Home. A spell has wiped Peter from the memory of everyone who knew him, including MJ (Zendaya) and his best friend Ned (Jacob Batalon). Peter now fights crime full time as Spider-Man, with no one to go home to. Meanwhile, he has to watch his old friends build lives without him.

That strain starts to change him in a way he may not be able to control. Then a new threat hits the city: a powerful villain that nobody can see. Peter also crosses paths with Frank Castle, the Punisher (Jon Bernthal). Sadie Sink and Tramell Tillman join in roles Marvel kept quiet, and we'll leave them that way. A few other familiar Marvel faces turn up too.

Tom Holland and the cast

In almost any Spider-Man Brand New Day review, Holland gets the first word of praise. He plays Peter as tired, lonely and older than his years, yet still light on his feet in the action. Several critics called it his most mature turn in the role.

Jon Bernthal is the other name that keeps coming up. His gruff Frank Castle and Holland's chatty Peter make an odd pair, and reviewers loved their scenes. Zendaya has less to do, since MJ no longer knows Peter. Even so, several critics felt she makes the most of every scene. Sadie Sink also drew praise for the quieter, more emotional moments. By contrast, a few critics missed the old trio and felt the film loses some charm by keeping the friends apart.

What works

Spider-Man swings between skyscrapers in Spider-Man: Brand New Day
Critics singled out the swinging through New York as a highlight. Image: Marvel Studios, Columbia Pictures. Via TMDB.

Director Destin Daniel Cretton, who made Shang-Chi and the Legend of the Ten Rings, keeps this story at street level. There is no multiverse this time, and critics were glad of it. The stakes are small by Marvel standards. Still, the personal stakes are high, and most reviewers felt that trade works.

The action is a big plus. The swinging through New York is fast and at times scary. Michael Giacchino's score also helps, especially in the scenes between Peter and MJ. There are some creepy, almost body-horror touches too, which set it apart from the earlier Holland films. In short, it feels like a film about Peter first and the wider Marvel world second.

Where it falls short

Pacing is the complaint in almost every mixed review. At 145 minutes, the film is long, and several critics found the first hour slow. Some plot turns are easy to guess, too. The villain is a strong idea on paper. Yet a few reviews felt the plan behind it doesn't hold up once you think about it.

Some critics found it fine but safe, and felt the series needs a bolder reset. A smaller group found it dull and gloomy. They are in the minority, though. Rotten Tomatoes has it at around 90% with critics, and Metacritic puts it at 70 out of 100.

Spider-Man Brand New Day review: should you watch it?

If you have followed Holland's Spider-Man since Spider-Man: Homecoming, yes. This is the most grown-up of his films. You do need to have seen No Way Home first, since the whole setup depends on it.

The film opened in cinemas in the UK on Wednesday, 29 July 2026, in India on Thursday, 30 July 2026 and in the US on Friday, 31 July 2026. It was a big hit in India, with ₹500.77 crore net at the time of writing, per the BuzzMelt movie page. Since Tuesday, 6 October 2026, it has been out digitally. Indian viewers can rent it on Prime Video (reported at ₹299) or Apple TV. US viewers can rent or buy it on Prime Video, Apple TV, Google Play, YouTube and Fandango at Home. UK viewers can rent or buy it on Prime Video, Apple TV and Sky Store. No subscription streaming date has been announced in any of the three countries.

Expect 2 hours 25 minutes. It is rated PG-13 in the US, 12A in UK cinemas and U/A 13+ in India. The violence is superhero action, with a few creepy moments that may upset younger children. Watch the official trailer on YouTube.

Sources: TMDB, Consequence, Screen, TheWrap, The Hollywood Reporter, The Guardian, Deccan Chronicle, JoBlo

Our verdict on Spider-Man: Brand New Day (2026)

4.5 4.5 out of 5 stars

Holland is at his best and the street-level story has real heart, but the slow first hour keeps it short of great. Worth it for fans.

This is BuzzMelt's own review. What members think of Spider-Man: Brand New Day is on its movie page.