BuzzMelt review

Lanterns review: Kyle Chandler and Aaron Pierre power a grounded, gripping DC mystery

Lanterns review: HBO's Green Lantern series sends veteran Hal Jordan and new recruit John Stewart to solve a murder in small-town Nebraska. Kyle Chandler and Aaron Pierre make a terrific odd couple and Kelly Macdonald shines as the sheriff. It leans hard on True Detective and sags in the back half, but it is one of the best superhero shows in years.

3.5 3.5 out of 5 stars Watch 100%

Lanterns review: a still from the HBO series Lanterns
Image: HBO, DC Studios. Via TMDB.

Most people still remember the 2011 Green Lantern film with Ryan Reynolds, and not fondly. HBO's Lanterns is about as far from that as a show can get. There are no big space battles in the opening hours, and very little glowing green. Instead, two cops drive around a small town and argue while they try to solve a murder. Our Lanterns review in short: it is one of the best superhero shows in years, even if it slows down near the end.

What Lanterns is about

Hal Jordan (Kyle Chandler) is a Green Lantern legend, a cosmic cop who has been at the job for a very long time. John Stewart (Aaron Pierre) is a former Marine and the new recruit he is meant to train. Their first case together brings them to rural Nebraska, where a man has been killed. The local sheriff, Kerry Kane (Kelly Macdonald), thinks she can handle it. Hal is sure something bigger is going on, and the mystery soon grows into a threat to the whole town.

The first season has eight episodes of about an hour each, and all of them are out now. In India, the show streams on JioHotstar.

Kyle Chandler and Aaron Pierre are the reason to watch

The pairing is the heart of the show. Chandler plays Hal as tired, stubborn and a little lonely, a man who has been a hero for so long he has forgotten how to be anything else. Pierre's John is younger, sharper and not willing to just follow orders. They clash constantly. Even so, the fights never feel like empty bickering. Each one tells you something about the other man.

Better still, the show gives both of them real backstories, and those stories feed into the case. John's parents get some of the most moving scenes in the season. Kelly Macdonald is a strong addition too. Her sheriff is calm, dry and nobody's fool, which makes her a good match for the two Lanterns.

Lanterns review: a still from the HBO series Lanterns
Image: HBO, DC Studios. Via TMDB.

A superhero show that plays like a crime drama

Damon Lindelof, Chris Mundy and Tom King made the show, and you can feel their style. It plays like a slow-burn detective story. The small-town setting gives it an unusual, grounded feel. The power rings are there, and they get used, but they never take over.

That choice will split viewers. If you want nonstop action, you will find very little of it, as only one episode really goes all out. Hardcore Green Lantern fans may also wish for more of the cosmic side. Most of the season stays firmly on Earth.

Where this Lanterns review has doubts

Lanterns wears its influences openly. The two cops on long drives, talking about life between crime scenes, will remind many viewers of True Detective. The dry humour and the mix of the everyday with the fantastic recall Lindelof's own Watchmen. None of it is a problem on its own. At times, though, it feels a little too familiar.

The bigger issue is the back half. Episodes six and seven slow the story right down, and the tension built in the early episodes starts to leak away. That leaves the finale with a lot of ground to make up. Either way, the season would have been stronger with a tighter final stretch.

Lanterns review: should you watch it?

Yes. This Lanterns review ends on a clear recommendation, especially for fans of crime dramas. Give it a go even if you don't care much about superheroes. The two leads are worth the time on their own, and the early episodes are gripping. Just don't expect a big, loud space adventure. For a taste of the tone, the official trailer is a good place to start.

Our verdict on Lanterns (2026)

3.5 3.5 out of 5 stars

A smart, slow-burn crime drama with two great leads, held back only by familiar influences and a sagging back half.

This is BuzzMelt's own review. What members think of Lanterns is on its series page.